NEW yORK  - Drawing attention to the massacre of Muslims in 2002 in the Indian State of Gujarat under his watch, a leading US newspaper said Narendra Modi, who was the State's chief minister and now opposition BJP's prime ministerial candidate, cannot hope to lead India effectively if he inspires "fear" and "antipathy" among many of its people, the New York Times commented Sunday.
"His rise to power is deeply troubling to many Indians, especially the country's 138 million Muslims and its many other minorities," the Editorial Board of the New York Times said in a sharp editorial on Modi, the Hindu nationalist leader.
But the newspaper did not say what action, if any, should the US take if Modi is elected as the head of Indian government. Washington has been deny him entry visa in protest against the killing of over 1,000 people, mostly Muslims, during the 2002 riots.
" Mr Modi has shown no ability to work with opposition parties or tolerate dissent, the editorial said, noting that he has already "alienated" BJP's political partners when Janata Dal (United), an important regional party broke off its 17-year alliance with the "party because it found Mr Modi unacceptable."
"India is a country with multiple religions, more than a dozen major languages and numerous ethnic groups and tribes. Mr. Modi cannot hope to lead it effectively if he inspires fear and antipathy among many of its people," said the editoria, which also questioned Modi's economic track record in Gujarat.
The "economic record in Gujarat is not entirely admirable, either," it said. "Muslims in Gujarat, for instance, are much more likely to be poor than Muslims in India as a whole, even though the state has a lower poverty rate than the country," the editorial said. The Times said, "Supporters of Mr. Modi argue that an investigation commissioned by India’s Supreme Court cleared him of wrongdoing in the riots. And they insist that Mr. Modi, who is widely admired by middle-class Indians for making Gujarat one of India’s fastest-growing states, can revive the economy, which has been weakened by a decade of mismanagement by the coalition government headed by the Indian National Congress Party.  "There is no question that the Congress Party has failed to capitalize on the economic growth of recent years to invest in infrastructure, education and public institutions like the judiciary.
And instead of trying to revive itself with new ideas and leaders, it is likely to be led in the coming election by Rahul Gandhi, the inexperienced scion of the Nehru-Gandhi family.
But Mr. Modi’s strident Hindu nationalism has fueled public outrage."